Classroom Card #4127
Fluid Mechanics – Small Water Tunnel Design Project
Summary
This project serves as a substitute for the final exam in Fluid Mechanics while integrating entrepreneurial mindset to promote active learning among students.
Course
Junior-level Fluid Mechanics
Time
Four to eight weeks
Materials
Key Concepts to Cover:
- Mass Conservation: Teach students the principle of mass conservation to ensure that fluid flow and continuity are properly accounted for in their designs.
- Extended Bernoulli Equation: Understanding the extended Bernoulli equation is crucial for analyzing pressure and velocity changes within the fluid system. This concept helps in estimating pump power required.
- Major and Minor Losses: Educate students on how to calculate both major losses (due to friction along the pipe) and minor losses (due to components such as fittings and valves). Accurate estimation of these losses is vital for effective design and performance.
- Pitot Tube: Introduce the Pitot tube as a device for measuring fluid velocity.
- Vena Contracta Effect: Explain the vena contracta effect, which can impact the accuracy of flow measurements and flow quality.
- Moody Chart: Utilize the Moody chart to help students understand the relationship between Reynolds number, pipe roughness, and friction factors.
Prerequisites
Engineering Dynamics
Description
Experiments help students gain insight to the fundamentals of fluid behaviors. One of the best tools for this is a a water tunnel (like a wind tunnel with fluids). In this project students are tasked with designing a portable water tunnel for a fictional company Dyntec. The design project described here is problem-based learning with EML, tailored for a junior-level fluid mechanics course.
Dyntec has noted that limitations in space, funding, and availability of qualified personnel lead to rentals at facilities which charge a high hourly charge, require security checks, and offer limited availability. To address these challenges, Dyntec has initiated a project to construct a small water tunnel for their research needs. Students will collaborate with the professor to grasp customer needs, identify crucial system components, and develop a small water tunnel.
Working in teams of 3-4, students primarily engage in the project outside of class over four weeks, with additional class sessions for guidance and team discussions. Regular meetings with the professor are scheduled to monitor student progress.
The water tunnel must be a small system with pipes, pumps, and typical components that meet customer requirements and demonstrate the students' knowledge of Fluid Mechanics. Students will conduct a cost analysis and comparing it with existing commercial products. The project includes submitting a preliminary "first-week" response, a preliminary report, and a final design report.
Curiosity
- Demonstrate constant curiosity about our changing world
Students must investigate the necessary components and materials for constructing a water tunnel. This includes identifying key elements like the structure, flow control systems, and observation windows, and choosing suitable materials such as acrylic, stainless steel, or composite polymers. The choice of material affects the manufacturing technique and overall cost.
Exploring new technologies like 3D printing is also essential, as it offers design flexibility, reduced material waste, and potentially lower production costs. Evaluating whether these advanced methods can be integrated into the design can enhance efficiency and performance.
Finally, a detailed cost analysis should be conducted to compare the expenses of constructing the water tunnel with those of commercial products, considering both initial costs and long-term maintenance.
Exploring new technologies like 3D printing is also essential, as it offers design flexibility, reduced material waste, and potentially lower production costs. Evaluating whether these advanced methods can be integrated into the design can enhance efficiency and performance.
Finally, a detailed cost analysis should be conducted to compare the expenses of constructing the water tunnel with those of commercial products, considering both initial costs and long-term maintenance.
- Explore a contrarian view of accepted solution
As the name implies, a water tunnel uses water as the primary fluid for testing. Students should consider consulting with Dyntec to determine the range of Reynolds numbers that can be achieved with their water tunnel setup. Additionally, they can explore the use of alternative fluids, such as mineral oil, which might offer different flow characteristics and advantages for specific experiments.
Connections
- Integrate information from many sources to gain insight
Students must investigate various factors, including pump power, the type of electricity required for the pump, electricity costs, sizing, and speed requirements based on customer information, along with a multitude of other non-technical considerations. All these aspects need to be integrated to develop a final design solution.
Additionally, students must select multiple components for their piping and pumping system from various sources, such as catalogs and suppliers. They need to ensure that these components are compatible and fit together properly. This selection process requires careful sequencing; for example, determining valve types, filters, pipe length, and the number of elbows, valves, and tees is essential before choosing the appropriately sized pump. Careful consideration and planning are crucial to ensure the system functions efficiently and effectively.
Additionally, students must select multiple components for their piping and pumping system from various sources, such as catalogs and suppliers. They need to ensure that these components are compatible and fit together properly. This selection process requires careful sequencing; for example, determining valve types, filters, pipe length, and the number of elbows, valves, and tees is essential before choosing the appropriately sized pump. Careful consideration and planning are crucial to ensure the system functions efficiently and effectively.
- Assess and manage risk
Losses associated with the piping system and tunnel components are estimates, including both minor losses (such as those caused by valves, elbows, tees, and filters) and major losses due to viscous flow. Typically, students should account for a "safety factor" when selecting a pump, using the extended Bernoulli equation learned in Fluid Mechanics. It is advisable to size the pump slightly larger than the calculated requirement, allowing for throttling down with a control valve if necessary. However, choosing a pump that is too large can result in excessive costs, so students must make their selection within practical and economical limits.
Additionally, the quality of flow, particularly at the test section, is influenced by the vena contracta effect, a concept studied in Fluid Mechanics. Students must consider strategies to mitigate this effect in their design to ensure accurate and reliable testing conditions.
Additionally, the quality of flow, particularly at the test section, is influenced by the vena contracta effect, a concept studied in Fluid Mechanics. Students must consider strategies to mitigate this effect in their design to ensure accurate and reliable testing conditions.
Creating Value
- Identify unexpected opportunities to create extraordinary value
Students have the opportunity to integrate a flow control system featuring a control panel and a Pitot tube, which measures fluid speed as discussed in Fluid Mechanics. It’s crucial to ensure that the device used for obtaining pressure readings from the Pitot tube is suitable for water if that’s the chosen testing fluid. Additionally, minimizing manual intervention in the system can boost the water tunnel’s efficiency, making it more effective and streamlined.
In parallel, students can leverage computational fluid dynamics (CFD) tools to simulate the flow field within the water tunnel based on their design parameters and conditions. This approach allows for a detailed analysis and optimization of the flow characteristics, further enhancing the overall performance of their design.
In parallel, students can leverage computational fluid dynamics (CFD) tools to simulate the flow field within the water tunnel based on their design parameters and conditions. This approach allows for a detailed analysis and optimization of the flow characteristics, further enhancing the overall performance of their design.
- Persist through and learn from failure
Students are likely to face challenges during their design process. For instance, they might select a pump before fully understanding the pressure requirements caused by system losses. They may also miss essential components like maintenance valves or flow control mechanisms. It's common for students to start their design calculations at a tricky or inappropriate point in the system, which can create problems down the line.
When encountering these issues, students should not hesitate to seek guidance from both the customer and the course instructor. The instructor can provide valuable insights to help navigate design challenges and resolve constraints, such as finding a pump that meets all necessary specifications. It’s also crucial for students to remember that pump selection must address both flowrate and pressure needs. Relying solely on one of these factors can result in a less effective solution. Balancing both requirements is key to choosing the right pump.
When encountering these issues, students should not hesitate to seek guidance from both the customer and the course instructor. The instructor can provide valuable insights to help navigate design challenges and resolve constraints, such as finding a pump that meets all necessary specifications. It’s also crucial for students to remember that pump selection must address both flowrate and pressure needs. Relying solely on one of these factors can result in a less effective solution. Balancing both requirements is key to choosing the right pump.
Log In to View More